Browse over 9,000 car reviews

Toyota RAV4 Cruiser vs Subaru Forester XT

Toyota RAV4 and Subaru Forester go head-to-head.

Toyota RAV4 Cruiser and Subaru Forester XT go head-to-head in this comparative review.

 

value

Toyota RAV4 Cruiser

from $42,990

Not super-cheap (add $2500 for a six-speed auto) but it gets dual-zone climate control, satnav, power tailgate, leather trim, sunroof, touchscreen and voice control infotainment, clever split-fold (flat) rear seats, trip computer and capped-price servicing.

Subaru Forester XT

from $43,490

This variant is CVT-only. There are USB and Bluetooth audio, trip computer, leather-wrapped wheel, dual-zone climate control, cloth trim, cruise control, whopper sunroof, one-touch flat split-fold rear seats and 18-inch alloys. It lacks satnav and some of the RAV4's power features.

design

Toyota RAV4 Cruiser

Not far from being a Corolla on stilts, the new-look RAV4 cuts a sharp figure -- but aggressive "chin'' and low-slung exhaust might not survive off-road, given ground clearance of about 160mm. Good rear cargo space, slightly eroded by full-size spare.

Subaru Forester XT

Chunky and familiar, it no longer sports a bonnet scoop for turbo models. Extra length and wheelbase give greater rear legroom. Cargo space -- 422L, less than RAV4 -- also suffers for the full-size spare. Ground clearance is 220mm and child seat anchor points are on seat backs.

technology

Toyota RAV4 Cruiser

No ground breaker but it's got the Camry's 2.5-litre four (132kW/233Nm), tuned for 91 RON and not as thirsty. The six-speed manual is sharp (albeit with a dead clutch pedal) and on-demand AWD shoves drive fore and aft as required, or it can lock 50-50 up to 40km/h.

Subaru Forester XT

Turbo 2.0-litre (177kW/350Nm) gives a big edge in oomph, similar thirst to the Toyota -- but for 95RON. Constant (and active) AWD and SI mode carry over, the latter now controlled from the steering wheel. The CVT makes good use of the outputs.

safety

Toyota RAV4 Cruiser

The list includes seven airbags (the standard six plus one for the driver's knees), AWD, stability and traction control, ABS, hill start assist, auto-dimming mirror, electronic diff lock, blind spot warning, HID auto headlights and rain-sensing wipers.

Subaru Forester XT

Five-star crash rating, with seven airbags (including driver's knee bag), ABS, stability and traction control (including X-Mode for off-road), reversing camera (but no sensors), xenon headlights and clever AWD.

driving

Toyota RAV4 Cruiser

Peppy power plant and comfortable, spacious cabin are offset by sharpish ride quality and odd boot design. Cabin noise suppression and body control are good and so are in-cabin storage and features list. But it's not the yardstick any more.

Subaru Forester XT

Subaru has stopped the "flare'' of revs in CVT to exploit meaty mid-range. Dynamics make the most of the outputs. Ride, though a little better than the RAV, is still too fiddly and there's some wind noise. AWD gives ample grip and balance.

Verdict

Toyota RAV4 Cruiser

Subaru Forester XT

Both tackle soft-roader tasks without concern. The Toyota has the features and boot space, the Subaru returns fire with more muscle and slightly better ride quality. Sales figures for 2013 reflect the Forester's superiority.